Best Free Encryption Utility for Cloud Storage

toggle-button

Submitted by philip | Last update on

Introduction

Most cloud storage services claim they "take every precaution" to keep your data secure. For example, most use encryption to make sure your files are secure in transit. They "have internal policies and controls" to ensure that employees don't access your files. But things do go horribly wrong.

For many cloud-storage users, privacy and robust encryption are top priorities. It is essential for data and documents to be encrypted before leaving their device, and it is essential that no other entities have their encryption key or any other way to gain clear-text access to their files.

On-the-fly encryption is the the most convenient way to protect your files in transit and in the cloud. That's where client-side products like SpiderOak, Tresorit, Sync and Cryptomator come in. Client-side on-the-fly encryption assures that your files never leave your computer in an unencrypted state. And your encryption key should never leave your computer.

Once it is properly set up, good client-side, on-the-fly encryption applications require no direct action by users. They and their client-side processes have fast, direct access to unencrypted files. But encryption adds complexity (things do go horribly wrong), and local backups are still important.

See also Encryption Methods at the end of this article.

 

Rated Products

SpiderOak  

Provides client-side encryption, automatic backup and sync with storage space.

Our Rating: 
4
License: Free (Limited features)
SpiderOak provides 2 GB of free cloud storage, along with client-side encryption. More storage is available for a fee. You can select as many local files or folders as you'd like - within the storage limit- for backup and sync. Your files are remain unencrypted on your synced devices, but are always encrypted before transmission and in the cloud.
SpiderOak keeps previous versions of files you back up - which is good - but those versions count against your 2 GB allocation. Although you can delete old file versions, 2 GB could get to be a little tight eventually. The user interface is logical, but it's a bit complex to discover it all if you want to use more than basic options.
Read full review...

Sync  

Provides sync, sharing, 5 GB of free storage and software to sync files with the encrypted cloud storage.

Our Rating: 
4
License: Free (Limited features)
Simple to install and simple to use. Clean and powerful with proven encryption. File versioning. Easily tailor what you want to sync and store on each of your devices. Sync and their servers are Located in Canada (no Patriot Act). Also has the "pluses" of Type 1 encryption as referenced in the Introduction section of this article.
The (minor) "minuses" of Type 1 encryption as referenced in the Introduction section of this article.
Read full review...

Cryptomator  

Free and open-source software provides transparent (on-the-fly), client-side encryption for cloud storage.

Our Rating: 
4
License: Free (Open source)
Open-source, which makes independent cryptographic review possible. Simple user interface and discovering features and settings is fairly intuitive. Compatible with a wide range of cloud storage services. Fast sync with the cloud. The wide range of cloud provider choices enables choice of features, functions and price. Client-side files are always encrypted at rest.
Can be challenging to set up the first time.
Read full review...

BoxCryptor  

Provides on-the-fly encryption giving you transparent access and quick cloud-sync for encrypted files.

Our Rating: 
2.5
License: Free (Limited features)
On-the-fly encryption gives you transparent access and quick sync for encrypted files when signed in. Strong security. Simple operation. For Windows, Mac, iPhone, iPad, and Android. Can be used to interface with several cloud-storage providers (limited to one choice in the free version).
The file system interface could lead to confusion, with files left unencrypted in the cloud (see discussion above). Requires Microsoft .NET. Only one encrypted folder is allowed in the free version, and it is limited to 2 GB.
Read full review...

Tresorit  

Provides seamless sync via the cloud, encrypted links for sharing and secure collaboration.

Our Rating: 
2
License: Free (Limited features)
Possibly the most secure choice of products listed here. A cloud storage account is included as part of the service. Tresorit has a clean, simple interface. Sync works quickly and well. Well written support documentation. You can recover previous versions of files. Has worked very reliably for me. Tresorit operates under Swiss laws, and uses Irish and Dutch servers (no Patriot Act).
The current free version is severely hobbled. See note in the discussion. Local files are not encrypted (but it's highly unlike that they will be lost in processing).
Read full review...

Cautionary Notes on Encryption

  1. Recent revelations about NSA crippling, or hacking encryption software are sobering if you store or transfer sensitive data via the internet. I would not suggest that it is prudent to trust any of the products listed here to protect your information from government agents or nation states, or determined cyber criminals.
  2. It still seems reasonable at this point to trust these products for protection from most hacker attacks.
  3. Operating systems are messy: Echoes of your personal data -- swap files, temp files, hibernation files, erased files, browser artifacts, etc -- are likely to remain on any computer that you use. For example, when you encrypt and compress files, clear-text versions that existed before you compress/encrypt the file or clear-text copies that are created after you decrypt/decompress it may remain on your hard drive. It is not difficult to extract those echoes.
  4. Further advice about how to use encryption are discussed in Encryption is Not Enough, including what you need  beyond encryption to be sure your private data is not lost or exposed.

New encryption applications often appear when an individual reads up on applied cryptography, selects or devises an algorithm, maybe even a reliable open source one, and then implements a user interface, tests the program to make sure it works, and thinks he's done. They are not. Such a program is certain to harbor fatal flaws.

"Functionality does not equal quality, and no amount of beta testing will ever reveal a security flaw. Too many products are merely buzzword compliant; they use secure cryptography, but they are not secure." --Bruce Schneier, in Security Pitfalls in Cryptography

 

Related Products

 

Encryption Methods

Common ways to implement on-the-fly, sometimes called transparent encryption

There are pitfalls and limitations in most systems for cloud-storage encryption. Perhaps you can spot them below, but this list might be best used as a reminder. Go learn more about these encryption methods in the Selecting an Encryption Method for Cloud Storage article and then come back here.

Type 1 = [Unencrypted folder] << >> [Integrated encryption & cloud sync] << >> [Cloud storage]

Examples: Tresorit | SpiderOak

Type 2 = [Virtual Drive - virtual clear-text files] << >> [Encryption] << >> [Folder - encrypted files] << >> [Cloud sync] << >> [Cloud storage]

Examples: BoxCryptor | Cryptomator | Cloudifile |

Type 3 = [User Folder - clear-text files] << >> [Encryption] << >> [Folder - encrypted files] << >> [Cloud sync] << >> [Cloud storage]

Example: Cloudfogger

Type 4 = [Virtual drive - clear-text files are virtual only] << >> [Encryption] << >> [Encrypted volume - single encrypted file] << >> [Cloud sync] << >> [Cloud storage]

Examples: VeraCrypt | TrueCrypt (not recommended, see in Related Products and Information below)

 

Editor

This category is maintained by volunteer editor philip. Registered members can contact the editor with any comments or suggestions they might have by clicking here.

Back to the top of the article.

Please rate this article: 

Your rating: None
4.48936
Average: 4.5 (47 votes)

Comments

I have been using BoxCryptor Classic locally for several years. Rather than attach to cloud directly, I've put the base encrypted files folder into OneDrive's local structure & let OneDrive do the sync work. I have about 15GB of files synced like that and access via 3 similarly configured Win10 PC's and 2 android devices. It has run like clockwork for 3 three years so far.

I just received notice from PKWare that Viivo will be shut down as of 1 July 2017 (but says servers will run until 1 July 2018).

Thanks for the heads-up bb1769,

I've remove Viivo. I don't know of any new alternatives.

Is Cryptomator Type 2 or Type 3 architecture? Under Encryption Methods it is listed as an example of Type 2. But in its Full Review, it says it is Type 3.

Thanks for the question. Cryptomator is Type 2 (fixed in Full Review). Files and folders are stored in an encrypted "vault" (structured/encrypting folder). You access them via a virtual drive, which has its own drive letter. So files and folders, including their names, are encrypted on your hard drive, and you enter your password in Cryptomator to open the virtual drive.

Hey, just FYI: cloudifile.com and cloudfogger.com are now both dead. Looks like maybe odrive.com (See: https://www.odrive.com/features/encryption) might be one to add but haven't tried it out yet.

Thanks for reporting their demise AEIO. I'll remove them from the category.

Which is more secure, Tresorit or Sync.com?

Tresorit is more seasoned, and it's what I use PoxyVX. I have no definitive basis for deciding which one is more secure. I just hope I've picked the right one.

I would like to be able to encrypt files before uploading them to a cloud service, without keeping a local copy. That is, I would like to be able to park files in an encrypted state on a web storage service of my choice, and not need to keep a copy on my hard drive. It would be amazing to be able to have an account with unlimited storage, like Amazon Drive, and just be able to upload files that I don't need to keep on my computer all the time, but may want to access again at some point. I'm envisioning a program that acts as a sort of middleman with one of these services - rather than having an encrypted folder on your hard drive and in the cloud storage, it would encrypt the file and upload it to the cloud storage. And also act as an interface to allow you to download the files again.

Is there any such program?

Not that I know of boombass. Microsoft may re-enable "placeholders" (web shortcuts) for OneDrive some day. Using placehoulders, you'd upload the file, but retain just the placeholder on your device. You'd simply download it if you needed it in the future. There maybe other cloud storage services that already do something similar.

One of the worst moves Microsoft made for Windows 10 was to removed OneDrive placeholders:

http://www.computerworld.com/article/2848118/microsofts-defense-of-onedr...

There is a kind of workaround creating a network drive to access OneDrive without having any files downloaded/off-line:

http://www.windowscentral.com/fix-placeholder-limitation-onedrive-window...

And I have heard that the OneDrive Windows Store App has placeholders but I haven't checked this myself.

I just signed up with https://www.sync.com . 5GB free plus 1GB bonus for doing five tasks. Website and/or app fully encrypted outside of your computer. Located in Canada since 2011. Don't lose your password - they don't have it and can't restore your files. Website is clean and fast. I am impressed.

Thanks for sharing this discovery DonsEars. I've started to vet/review this service, as it looks quite nice.

Phillip, You compare BoxCrytor and SafeMonk to Cloudfogger, but you never actually talk about Cloudfogger. Maybe you deleted it when editing or something? Hopefully, you have a backup. Also, I'm pretty interested in what you think about Cloudfogger. I just dropped AxCrypt do to the direction they are going and what I consider a very high price. I'm looking for a solution to replace it and Cloudfogger is high on my "maybe" list.

You can now read what I have to say about Cloudfogger. There is one big security concern, but if you just want to encrypt files locally and not upload them to the cloud it works fairly nicely because local encryption is integrated with the file system and you can do your encryption/unencryption with just a right-click in the native file-manager.
Turns out that Cloudfogger appeared to be moribund a couple of years ago. So I removed the bulk of references to Cloudfogger. Maybe it was just a case of a neglected website. They seem to have refreshed the website, and are continuing maintenance of Cloudfogger. So, back to work...
I'm on it DocFallingApart. Thanks for telling me Cloudfogger is missing. Yes I have been heavily editing this article, and I seem to remember not seeing Cloudfogger there myself. Probably lost my mental note. ;)

Wow! Nice update on the article. It's a huge help with finding the right solution for users with varying computer skills. You da MAN! Thanks!

hello all, TRESORIT is not free anymore, please update.
besides, thanks for all the worthfull information !

The free version still exists. MC - Site Manager.
https://tresorit.com/pricing/basic
"Do I have to pay to use Tresorit?
You can always switch to Tresorit Basic, offering 3GB of storage for free. You can share securely with a few people, but won't be able to set access permissions, manage other users or set policies. If you wish to start using Tresorit Basic for free, get started here".

I've fixed our link.

Philip, Tresorit has changed their Plan structure:
Users who sign up after Jun. 30, 2016 get the Reader plan, not Basic! Among other big CONS, is only 1gb of space, only one device can be associated with an account, and you can only have 1 Tresorit folder. It sounds like the Basic plan is much nicer, but I'm out of luck. You may want to update the Tresorit section of this article.

I tried to post a link to the exact Tresorit article, but the spam filter would not let me post it. So, Google "tresorit reader" and click on the link "What is the Reader Plan?"

Thanks for your research and comment, Autohost1. Yes, Tresorit Reader Plan is severely hobbled compared to the original free plan [details]. I will take action to change our review.

Well done MC :-) , but no way (for me) to find the link to this page.
So thank u for the direct one

I guess they wouldn't make the free option easy to find. :D On their main page, scroll down and click the "Pricing" link and then the free link is contained within the "Frequently asked questions" section lower down on that same page. MC - Site Manager.

Just checked out Tresorit, and their free storage is down to 3GB, not 5GB anymore.

Thanks FlyingHawk. Duly noted. Some free ways to increase storage to 5GB after you install Tresorit are still available though.

Wuala has announced they're shutting down. They are recommending that users switch to Tresorit, as they think Tresorit can take good care of their data. Tresorit has a tool to get your data out of Wuala and into Tresorit.

Based on several review sites, we chose Vivo for encryption of corporate files on Dropbox (about 200,000 files with 20 users).

There is no user guide for Vivo and there are 2 versions of the product. Responses by email from the company were minimal.

After two months of frustration and wasted labor hours, we gave up. The software may indeed be as good as the reviews indicate. Add in the costs of implementation since there is no user manual.

Pages