Best Free Spam Filter for Experienced Users

 
In a Hurry?
  Go straight to the Quick Selection Guide
Introduction

Many spam filters are available employing lots of different techniques. In my experience "learning" spam filters that use the Bayesian statistical approach out-perform most other types of filters. Not only are they better at detecting spam, they are also less liable to classify your real mail as spam.

This effectiveness takes a little time to develop as the filter has to be trained to recognize your spam from your normal mail. It takes a week or so before results start becoming accurate and best results may take a month or more.

As this is designed for experienced users, I will give a tip that might be confusing for the average users. Is it really a spam, or a service site you signed up for and don't want anymore?

Take a look at the e-mail and if it is from a company you ordered something from or signed up to receive e-mail from, then it may be something you don't want, but is not really spam. If so unsubscribe from the site itself. Say if the e-mail is from amazon.com and you ordered from them, go to the site and unsubscribe to the newsletter etc. If it is "legitimate" spam don't click the unsubscribe link.

Discussion

POPFile was one of the first Bayesian filters and is still one of the best. It works as a proxy mail server so that it can be used with any POP email client. Setup is reasonably straightforward for experienced users but beginners may be better off with Mailwasher.

Spamato is a promising, free open source spam filter with a difference. Rather than rely on one Bayesian spam filter to classify spam, Spamato uses a "multifaceted spam filter system that combines a variety of anti-spam techniques". Like POPFile, it can work with any email client but additional plugins are available to integrate Spamato into Outlook, Thunderbird and the Mozilla Mail Client.

Other excellent free Bayesian spam filters available include SpamBayes and K9. Both are simple to install though, like all statistical filters, they need to go through a training phase before they reach full effectiveness.

A newer addition to this list is Spam Terrier from Agnitum. If you are new to Bayesian spam filters and use Outlook, you will find this program is a tad easier to install and use than SpamBayes or K9.

 

Other spam filters to be reviewed:

Spamihilater, Ella, Email remover, eXpurgate, SpamPal, Epam Experts Desktop, Cactus Spam Filter, SpamRIP, Bullguard Spam Filter, G-Lock Spam Combat, SpamWeasel, GMail Service.

If you have any experience with any of these, please feel free to share that info in the forum or give your comments at the end of this article.

Related Products and Links

You might want to check out these articles too:

Quick Selection Guide

POPFile    Rating 9 of 10  Gizmo's Top Pick

Pros   Works as a proxy mail server, can be used with any POP email client. Setup is reasonably straightforward for experienced users.
Cons   Beginners may be better off with Mailwasher.
Developer Home Page   http://popfile.sourceforge.net/
Download link   http://getpopfile.org/download
File Size   5.2 MB   Version 1.1.0   License Type Unrestricted Freeware   Installation Requirements Windows 95, 98, Me, NT, 2000, XP, Vista, Mac OS, Linux, Unix
Info   Additional Software Required: Requires Perl and Microsoft Outlook or Outlook Express. Supports the following protocols: POP3, SSL POP3, IMAP, HTTP (MSN, Yahoo, AOL), Exchange (with Outclass extension).

Spamato    Rating 8 of 10

Pros   Uses a “multifaceted spam filter system that combines a variety of anti-spam techniques”. Like POPFile, it can work with any email client.
Cons   Requires additional plugins to integrate Spamato into Outlook, Thunderbird and the Mozilla Mail Client.
Developer Home Page   http://www.spamato.net/
Download link   http://www.spamato.net/
File Size   4.97 MB   Version 0.99.9   License Type Unrestricted Freeware   Installation Requirements Windows NT, 2000, XP, Vista, Mac OS, Linux
Info   Additional Software Required: Java 5 (JRE) Environment or higher, .NET Framework 1.1 or higher (if using Outlook plugin in Windows). Supports the following protocols: POP3, IMAP.

SpamBayes    Rating 7 of 10

Pros   Simple to install.
Cons   Like all statistical filters, need to go through a training phase before reaching full effectiveness.
Developer Home Page   http://spambayes.sourceforge.net/
Download link   http://spambayes.sourceforge.net/
File Size   2.88 MB   Version 1.0.4   License Type Unrestricted Freeware   Installation Requirements Windows 98, Me, NT, 2000, XP, Vista, Mac OS, Linux, Unix
Info   Supports the following protocols: POP3, IMAP

K9    Rating 7 of 10

Pros   Simple to install.
Cons   Like all statistical filters, need to go through a training phase before reaching full effectiveness.
Developer Home Page   http://www.keir.net/k9.html
Download link   http://www.keir.net/k9.html
File Size   113 KB   Version 1.2.8   License Type Unrestricted Freeware   Installation Requirements Windows 95, 98, Me, NT, 2000, XP
Info   Supports the following protocols: POP3

Spam Terrier    Rating 6 of 10

Pros   Outlook users will find this program is a tad easier to install and use than SpamBayes or K9.
Cons    More suitable for Outlook users only.
Developer Home Page   http://www.agnitum.com/products/spam-terrier/index.php
Download link   http://www.agnitum.com/products/spam-terrier/index.php
File Size   1.38 MB   Version 2.0   License Type Unrestricted Freeware   Installation Requirements Windows 98, Me, 2000, XP, Vista, 2003 Server, 2008 Server
Info   Additional Software Required: Requires Microsoft Outlook or Outlook Express. Supports the following protocols: POP3, SSL POP3, IMAP, HTTP (MSN, Yahoo, AOL), Exchange.
Editor

This software category is maintained by volunteer editor radu

Tags

spam, spams, free filter, free spam filter, freeware

Back to the top of the article

 

3.5
Average: 3.5 (2 votes)
Your rating: None

you will find mailwasher review in the spam filter for average user section

I have been using Mailwasher 2.0.28 beta for years and did not have any problem with it
It manages multiple accounts (I have 8 of them on 4 different suppliers) even web mail like yahoo, but I did not succeed in accessing my Gmail account.
Sometimes (once every 3 months or so) it suddenly freezes, I just terminate it thru task manager and restart it from my quick launch bar, and this is it, no data is lost.

It still can be found on the Internet as explained in the other section

Hope this helps!

You mention Mailwasher in the POPFile review but it gets no mention other than that

There's a freeware version of Mailwasher as well as the payware version. Free version can only handle one mail account, but it seems that it can now be a POP, Hotmail, IMAP, GMail or AOLMail account.

Ive tried to obtain a Spam Terrier license 3 times.. is this product still valid?.. they never send a e mail license to use the product..??

Maybe you can add Spam Fighter to the list of filters you will be reviewing?

Its $29 and thus... not freeware.

Thank you for confirming this is not freeware.

I'm surprised no one has has mentioned Spamihilator
http://www.spamihilator.com
This is a very simple application sits between the email server and your client so spam almost never get into the client. It does require some training and I have added my own spam words but after a few weeks you will not get any spam in your client.
It even has an option where the spam is left on the email server and is deleted when you delete the spam.

I have tried plenty of others but I keep coming back to Spamihilator.

Spamato takes 700K of RAM. It worked well, but I couldn't keep Outlook open with it installed. Spam Terrier can only monitor one inbox which for me is a deal killer.

I just wanted to take a moment to thank you for turning me on to Spam Terrier. What a GREAT little app and very easily integrated into Outlook Express as a plug-in. Nice!

http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,2845,2342378,00.asp

your views gizmo?

is spam fighter better than the other 2?

wish to rely on you as the final authority without having to compare other reviews.

I installed spamato on outlook and it does a great job of filtering spam but it is a huge memory hog. I do not recommend it.

gmail.... any spam filter can filter out all the spam, trouble is that only a few like gmail can avoid to put almost any legitimate mail in the spam box.

Having to work through your spam box on a regular basis completely defeats the purpose of a spam filter. Therefore, if you can't use something like gmail then I would suggest getting a weaker spam filter that lets some spam through but doesn't mark good mail as spam. This is especially important if you run a business or use email for work.

I would avoid any spam filter that uses bayesian filtering like the plague (so probably most of them). I would go with gmail or there was some spam proxy, forget the name, that worked on a central database of spam messages. That is the best way to implement a spam filter, by letting users flag what is spam so that other users may benefit.

Is it possible that this section could be expanded to include web browser ad block apps?

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <b> <address> <blockquote> <br> <caption> <center> <code> <dd> <del> <div> <dl> <dt> <em> <font> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <i> <img> <li> <ol> <p> <pre> <span> <strong> <sub> <sup> <table> <tbody> <td> <tfoot> <th> <thead> <tr> <u> <ul> <tr>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • [node:123] - insert full text (themed by theme('node'))
    [node:123 body] - insert node's body
    [node:123 teaser] - insert node's teaser
    [node:123 link] - insert link to node
    [node:123 collapsed] - insert collapsed node's body
  • You may use [view:viewname] tags to display listings of nodes.

More information about formatting options