Gizmos Needs You

Gizmo's Freeware is Recruiting

 We are looking for people with skills or interest in the following areas:
 -  Mobile Platform App Reviews for Android and iOS
 -  Windows, Mac and Linux software reviews       Interested? Click here

                  

 

Best Free Project Manager

 
Introduction

Project Management software can be a minefield; every user has a different view of what makes a program “project management” material rather than a good organizing tool or time manager.

While Microsoft lead the way in desktop project management tools with MS Project, not everyone wanted the complexity that came with all of its capabilities.

For our review, we have concentrated on those programs which offer standard project management features such as task and resource scheduling and tracking, charting, project and task breakdown into sub-projects, sub-tasks and dependencies.

 
In a Hurry?

Go to details...  Go straight to the Quick Selection Guide

 
Discussion

Open WorkbenchTopping our list here is the Open Source project management tool Open Workbench, which is a free tool so feature-rich and powerful that it should at least be considered before any decision is made to purchase a commercial project management package. Like the commercial products of the same ilk, it takes time to get your head around and if you have been using Microsoft Project or another task-based manager you'll have to re-orient your thinking because Open Workbench is resource-driven not task-driven.

According to the developers, "an Open Workbench plan is built up from estimates for the tasks of work. Estimates are tied to the resource assigned to the tasks. Duration is then driven by the number of hours each resource will work per week to cover the total number of hours required for the tasks. Open Workbench is best suited to groups that estimate total work effort based on the estimates for all the tasks associated with a project and then create a staffing plan and schedule for those estimates."

The key features of the application include project planning, scheduling, resource management, project review and more.

The program can also read Microsoft project files and this possibly makes Open Workbench the most appealing. Many products–even the commercial offerings–are great project management tools but sooner or later someone is going to want to view or edit your plan with the ubiquitous MS Project and without compatibility, the best you are going to be able to offer is an exported spreadsheet or graphical equivalent.

Open Workbench is the real thing, not some amateurish, half baked effort. Like Microsoft Project, it is best suited to large scale projects that can justify the considerable time it takes to learn the product.

Users with smaller projects or more simple needs might want to consider some of the less feature-rich project managers, such as GanttProject or ToDoList.

 

GanttPVGanttProject is a very good project management tool, with a surprisingly good depth of features and accessories for a free product. It is distributed under a GNU General Public License, which means you can download it for free.

There is also a java based version of the program, which means that you don't even have to download the software to use it. As its name suggest, GanttProject is excellent for making Gantt charts, which are great  for making logical and easy to understand development plans.

On of the features I particularly liked was the ability to put in a percentage complete bar inside the timeline of that particular stage. This makes it easy to see how far along everything is without a lot of hassle. The program, if you use the downloadable version is very simple and easy to use. You can add as many tasks as you need, as well as then being able to assign personnel and resources to each task.  In particular the features for the personnel section are very good. You can add team members for a project and assign them to tasks when you set them up, you can also input e-mail addresses as well as phone numbers for each person and assign them a role in the group. GanttProject also includes a Milestone feature which is very useful, giving an end goal to aim for with a fixed time. Many other project management tools do not support these.

On the technical side, GanttProject can save files as .xml files, which means that they are viewable over the internet as well as transferable to other programs, such as Microsoft Project. The installation is very quick and the program is actually very small, being under 10mb. There are very few problems with this tool, my only criticism is that you can't associate files with particular tasks, allowing other team members to get the files they need.

Overall GanttProject is a very good project management tool, perhaps not suitable for very large projects, but very usable for small to medium size projects

 

dotProject is a robust Web-based project management framework written in PHP that allows users to schedule, plan, and staff projects. It's not a perfect application, but its extensive functionality and ease of use make its shortcomings easy to overlook.

The dotProject application is an open source GNU GPL-licensed project management application that was started in December 2000 and is actively developed and maintained. By way of an intuitive browser-based interface, dotProject offers project task management (task description, duration, scheduling, and assignment), multi-user support, granular user permissions, Gantt charts, discussion forums, file checkout, contact list, trouble tickets, reporting, calendar, and user-based to-do capabilities. If that's not enough built-in functionality, you can extend dotProject from a well-trafficked SourceForge project full of additional add-on modules.

A simple tabbed user menu drives the application. The fundamental units of the dotProject system are companies, projects, tasks, and users. The first step in using dotProject is to create companies for which projects are to be completed. Users, projects, and tasks are all related to a company. The next step should be to add users to both your client company listings and to your own resource allocation. You need users so that you have someone to assign tasks to; otherwise the administrator gets to do all the work! You can assign users varying degrees of permissions that can be matched to specific companies and/or projects.

After you've set up your company and initial users it's time to create project details that need to be managed and input tasks. Tasks can be linked and labeled as predecessor tasks and/or milestones and assigned to user resources. Users are notified of their task assignments by email, which is a neat feature. Users can also simply log in to the system and examine their own task lists.

Task management is the critical component of any project management application, and it's something that dotProject does reasonably well. Users can log time against a task directly in the system, giving a project manager a good synopsis of progress to date. From a scheduling point of view, dotProject helps users to calculate when tasks should start and when they should be completed based on time duration allocated and start task dependencies.

DotProject also allows users to create something called dynamic tasks, which takes their start, completion, and duration from the child tasks that are related to them. The newly updated and thorough dotProject documentation has some excellent explanation of how dotProject handles tasks, dynamic tasks, and dependencies.

Love them or hate them, Gantt charts are a mainstay of many project management packages. DotProject, rather than making the Gantt chart the focus of project management as they are in GanttProject, simply includes the chart as one of its tabs. DotProject offers no default export or print functionality for Gantt charts.

Project managers tend to love their reports. DotProject can generate a number of project reports, including task log, user performance, allocated user hours, tasks sorted by user, tasks overdue, completed, upcoming, overall report, and project statistics.

Overall, dotProject offers a staggering amount of useful functionality. By virtue of it being a Web-based multi-user application, you can quickly put it to work for either individual or distributed team project development. Its online documentation and support forums help when you need to figure something out or have hit a snag. Certainly dotProject is not without issues; the developers maintain a list of documented bugs that need to be dealt with in upcoming releases. Items like the Gantt project bug are annoying but are easily fixed with a small code tweak.

On the whole, dotProject is a solid multi-user project management tool that stands on its own merits.

 

web2projectTo run web2project you have to have "self host" your own web server (Apache or Microsoft IIS, with PHP and MySQL) or use a web hosting provider. If you're unsure about doing it yourself then reading the installation instructions will give you a clear idea whether you can do it. For this reason, web2project ismore likely to appeal to IT professionals.

web2project split from dotProject in 2007 when dotProject started its own redevelopment process. As its name suggests web2project had clear aims and they've certainly improved the visual appearance over dotProject.Unfortunately web2project is still working on becoming the complete project manager. But you have the option to start in dotProject and then migrate your project to Web2project although the reverse is not possible.

The application is well documented in a user guide and has video tutorials. There is also a Microsoft Project import tool.

Overall, it takes more time to setup the projects than the other options. However its strength is in collaborative projects with shared calendars. It will push events to Google Calendar and iCalendar. It has the ability ability to work with as many companies, departments, and users as you want. You can produce Gantt charts for individual projects or overall groups. It also has a Risk Management module to for monitoring the specific risks associated with individual tasks or entire projects.

 

ToDoListToDoList is not a traditional project manager. It is really a task list with some project management features. It does not have the mandatory Gantt charting and emphasis on critical paths, nor does it schedule using the usual task duration or effort. That means it is quite awkward for a team to use for collaborative tasks because you'll have to schedule tasks manually. It would work better for a team leader who hands out tasks to each team member. It is probably best for an individual who simply wants to track what has to be done, how long it will take, and who is doing things for us that we depend on. Tasks can have many sub-tasks some of which are dependencies that must be completed for the parent task to be completed.

It is relatively simple to use but if you get stuck some of the documentation is overly complicated for the type of users that it will appeal to. How effective it is for you will depend upon how elegantly you structure your tasks. It makes it easier by being able to attach notes, set due dates, get alarms/reminders, and have simple links to Microsoft Outlook.

Colour coding of tasks is also useful but what I really liked is the ability to link symbols to tasks to make them stand out.

 
Quick Selection Guide

Open Workbench
5
 
Gizmo's Freeware award as the best product in its class!

Runs as a stand-alone program on a user's computer
Feature-rich and powerful effort-based so it best suited to groups that estimate total work effort.
Resource-driven (effort-based) rather than task driven (duration-based) like Microsoft Project.
1.1.6
9.03 MB
32 bit but 64 bit compatible
Unrestricted freeware
Windows 2000, XP or 2003 Server Edition.

Additional software required: Version 1.5 or later of Sun's Java Runtime Engine.

On 64-bit Windows running the 64-bit Java Runtime you will get the message "Cannot start or find the Java 1.5 JRE. The 1.5 JRE may not have been installed or the registry may be incorrect." To resolve this you can install the 32-bit Java Runtime 1.6 from http://filehippo.com/download_jre_32/3868/. It will not affect your 64-bit runtime.

The version 1.1.6 user guide is available at:
ftp://ftp.psu.ac.th/pub/openworkbench/OpenWorkbench_Guide_ENU.pdf
http://www.scribd.com/doc/20820000/Open-Workbench-User-Guide

If you are interested in the unsupported version 2 beta then see http://workbenchwarrior.wordpress.com/2012/03/09/installing-open-workbench/

GanttProject
4
 
Runs as a stand-alone program on a user's computer
Available for Windows, Mac OS X and Linux.
Lacks the looks and some of the functionality of Open Workbench.
http://www.ganttproject.biz/
2.6.6
13.3 MB
32 bit but 64 bit compatible
Open source freeware
There is no portable version of this product available.
Windows XP to 8; Mac OSX; Linux

Requires the Java Runtime version 1.6 or higher

v2.6.6.r1715

dotProject
4
 
Is a web service or web application
Web based tool; long history of succesful use; has a large active user base with effective community support if you have a problem.
Uninspiring website lacks the look and feel of other web based tools; bugs are often slow to be fixed.
http://www.dotproject.net/
2.1.7
Unrestricted freeware
There is no portable version of this product available.
Web based.
web2project
4
 
Combines a web service with a stand-alone program
Web-based; more good for collaborative projects with shared calendars; can migrate projects from dotProject; screenshots and video tutorials
You have to install your own web server or get a hosted account; Some features previously available at dotProject are still being developed
http://web2project.net/
3.1
4.06
32 bit but 64 bit compatible
Open source freeware
Windows; Linux; OS/X

Most users should read the installation instructions before deciding to use web2project. If you are not comfortable with the instructions then consider another product:
http://wiki.web2project.net/index.php?title=Installation

Requires MySQL, PHP and a common web hosting platform like Apache or IIS

ToDoList
3
 
Runs as a stand-alone program on a user's computer
Simple tasks without resources and dependencies; Easy to get started managing a simple project; Lots of help for starters including a tutorial project;
Does not come with the mandatory Gantt charting
6.8.10
2.08 MB
32 bit but 64 bit compatible
Unrestricted freeware
Windows 98 to Vista

A range of plugins is freely available, including a PocketPC viewer and an MS Project 2002 converter.

 
Editor

This software category is in need of an editor. If you are interested in taking it over then check out this page for more details. You can then contact us from that page or by clicking here.

 
Tags

project manager, gantt chart, work bench, to do list, free software, freeware

Back to the top of the article.

 

Share this
4.157895
Average: 4.2 (57 votes)
Your rating: None

Comments

by Gil Mensch on 30. April 2013 - 13:55  (107397)

ReqMan appears no longer to be freeware. It just has a 14-day free trial with pricing thereafter starting at $9/month.

by MidnightCowboy on 2. June 2013 - 8:08  (108212)

Thank you for letting us know. It is now removed from the review. MC - Site manager.

by Gil Mensch on 30. April 2013 - 13:32  (107395)

Does anyone have experience with Asana? ( http://asana.com/ ) I was searching for a web-based app of this type. Asana came up early in Google search results, and it looks interesting, but I see no mention of it here either in the article or in the comments section. Just wondering. Asana says it is free for up to 30 users/project participants.

by SJB (not verified) on 23. November 2012 - 23:55  (102820)

I teach upper level college students and we do a fair number of group projects. Which of these applications would be best for students--some use Macs, some use PCs, some are on tablets, all have access to desktop labs with both Mac and PC computers. This is a large commuter school, so I'm constantly looking for tools they can use to avoid driving all over the place.

by ogian on 24. November 2012 - 0:42  (102821)

Let me say up front that it is difficult to find a "free" web based project management tool that is actually free. Most that were initially free are now commercial tools. Having said that, I would recommend PHProjekt (http://www.phprojekt.com/), which is an open source web application. I haven't written a review about it yet but based on initial research and your requirements, this is my recommendation.

by ilana (not verified) on 16. October 2012 - 7:12  (100823)

I've started trying out GanttProject, which seems to have all the functionality we need. I am a first time user of any project management tool, and I can't figure out whether it is possible to input and view multiple projects concurrently, allowing you to view a resource's capacity across various projects they may be involved in. Thanks.

by ogian on 17. October 2012 - 15:29  (100914)

You might want to check out the GanttProject forum at the following link: http://forum.ganttproject.biz/view/20120822202531_-4b9mzmf95256sv91k1d7v...

by yuyu (not verified) on 16. July 2012 - 1:23  (96234)

I would like to try this product and i think it is useful for me.

by CHRIS4567 (not verified) on 17. June 2012 - 16:46  (95008)

The problem with online project mgmt tools, is that someone out there, can see all your plans, and details.
No confidentiality , especially crucial in these days of business spying, and hackers.

I prefer something that can be run on my desktop only.

by Oz (not verified) on 11. June 2012 - 22:04  (94706)

Have you tried Birdview Projects Ogian? (www.birdviewprojects.com)

I'm curious about your opinion. It is a fully featured product that is also completely free, and has a very easy to use interface. Let me know what you think, and how it compares to your top choices!

by ogian on 11. June 2012 - 23:47  (94712)

I have not tried Birdview Projects yet. My question would be just how human centric it really is? In my experience team collaboration falls apart the more complex a project is. It does look interesting enough for me to take a look at. I can't promise anything though.

by Babynus (not verified) on 31. May 2012 - 14:12  (94243)

List could be completed with Project'Or RIA (http://projectorria.toolware.fr).
This simple to use tool gets a growing community, mostly thanks to its ergponomy and variety of functionalities.
Most of here above tools only focus on one task : Gantt planning, or tasks list, or resource management.
Project'Or RIA does all of this, and much more.

by ogian on 11. June 2012 - 23:39  (94711)

I haven't taken a look at this yet but you are correct in that most of the tools reviewed here do focus on one of the three tasks that you mentioned.

by Sergii (not verified) on 4. September 2011 - 10:23  (78987)

GanttPV = portable = good!

by ogian on 14. December 2011 - 16:49  (85019)

GanttPV is good and the most important feature for me is that it is supported on multiple platforms.

-- Ogian

by mouse user (not verified) on 25. July 2011 - 14:00  (76212)

I use a easy and free http://projects-manager.com/en/

by ogian on 26. July 2011 - 16:21  (76262)

Thank you.

by matandi (not verified) on 14. June 2011 - 13:16  (73786)

Hi,

I am using OpenProj 1.4.

I would like to add a sub-project to my existing project.

Apparently, I cannot find the Project button in the insert menu, as described in the Sub-projects documentation.

http://openproj.org/wiki/index.php?ti...

I will be grateful for any help on the subject.

All the best,

by ogian on 15. June 2011 - 16:50  (73847)

Hello, I just installed OpenProj 1.4 for windows and I couldn't find a project button on the insert menu either. I would suggest contact serena.com. Contact information for OpenProj is at http://www.serena.com/products/openproj/index.html. Good luck.

by pierrecogitae (not verified) on 25. May 2011 - 9:52  (72656)

Hi there.
Ganttproject is free, opensource, simple and pretty good.
http://www.ganttproject.biz/

CHeers

by marcogon (not verified) on 17. May 2011 - 11:42  (72082)

Here`s a huge list of such software as well: http://www.vivalogo.com/vl-resources/free-project-management-software-systems.htm

by ogian on 17. May 2011 - 17:43  (72113)

Thank you for the information.

by Mandeep Mehta (not verified) on 31. March 2011 - 11:18  (68904)

I am unable to access web site of open work bench.

by ogian on 4. May 2011 - 16:22  (71411)

It appears that as of this moment, Open Workbench does not have a home page. You can still download it at open-workbench.en.softonic.com. An open workbench start video is available at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Luip3tPbThY/.

by Mikki White (not verified) on 16. February 2012 - 18:35  (88932)

Thank you... couldn't find it either and it seems its the one most recommended.

by ogian on 2. May 2011 - 13:37  (71285)

I was also unable to access the open work bench website. I will look into this and send a reply once I have more information.

by Anupam on 31. March 2011 - 12:59  (68972)

Yes, it seems to be down at the moment

by Anonymrezaei-mehdious (not verified) on 4. January 2011 - 9:40  (63769)

check out openproj,it is similar to ms project

by Lars (not verified) on 27. October 2010 - 9:05  (60266)

We use a great free web based tool from http://www.requirementone.com called ReqMan. It is all free and it has a vast functionality that we can use for project management, requirement management, questionnaires for our users, claims system, RFQs and RFPs for our suppliers and much more. I would like to recommend it to anybody.

by Anonymousca (not verified) on 31. March 2011 - 6:07  (68863)

reqman seems good.but it can't be downloaded and installed locally?this is required since we work in intranet,and not internet access.