Gizmo's Freeware is Recruiting
We are looking for people with skills or interest in the following:
- Mobile Platform Reviews
- Rootkit Scanner and Remover
- Streaming Media Recorder
- Email Client
- Archive Manager Interested? Click here
Best Free BitTorrent Client
|
In a Hurry?
|
|
|
|
Introduction
|
|
Since its inauspicious public appearance just under 12 years ago bittorrent has become one of the major download formats. With good reason too: it's fast, equitable and efficient. For the downloader, bittorrent offers an uncorrupted copy of the original with the option to stop the download at any time and re-start from where the download left off (very useful for those on shaky internet connections) This article is part of a series of articles on bittorrent here at Gizmo's Freeware. If you are not familiar with bittorrent, then before using this article you should read this: There are setup guides here at Gizmo's Freeware for each of these suggested free bittorrent clients. Links to the guides are with the product description in the Quick Selection Guide at the end of the review. This review was prepared on February 8, 2013, and the testing was conducted in the two weeks before that date and used the latest versions of the clients at that time. Testing Anyone with knowledge of bittorrent knows that it is nearly impossible to have a testing procedure that is foolproof in measuring small differentials in speed among bittorrent clients. This is due to the fact that your download speed depends on the upload of other active users and there is no control over their actions while testing. However, I have been testing clients for this category for several years and am convinced that the better clients can be separated from the others. There were 7 rounds of testing to boil down the 17 clients tested to the 7 in the review. Six torrents and three magnet links were used in this part of the testing. I then conducted several tests in two rounds of testing to determine the Top Pick. I did post pdf copies of my notes for each round of testing: Bittorrent Testing 2013 Notes All of the clients listed in the review had excellent performance on all of the testing, so all are superior bittorrent clients. The speed performance on the testing was a factor. Even though the speed differences were small, some consistently performed slightly better. Features and support were also factors. CPU and RAM mattered in that a client without many features that had high CPU or RAM use would fall to one with low CPU/RAM use. Toolbars and addons in the installation process were a slight factor. Testing was performed on Windows 7 64bit. About Me I am not a technical expert, but I have been using bittorrent since 2003. Before coming to Gizmo's I was the Administrator at a general bittorrent forum site, giving assistance on a variety of clients, and a moderator at the Vuze fora. I still view a number of bittorrent fora and the fora of the various bittorrent clients. This gives me a good idea of what the average user is looking for in a bittorrent client. Ranking All of these clients have the basic bittorrent features like DHT, PEX, encryption and UPnP. All seven of the bittorrent clients listed here performed excellently on all test torrents. Speed and performance was a factor, but features and support facilities were major considerations. A clean installation (without toolbars or ads) was a plus. Most people just want a client to download torrents, but there are some features that a number of users like to use, such as a built in IP Filter, use of RSS feeds, proxy support, a scheduler and a web interface. I will make note of those that have installs or other changes to your system that are not necessary for the proper function of the bittorrent client. I strongly suggest that if you choose a bittorrent client that has these unnecessary add ons, to not accept those changes or add ons. I have put up guides to help with the installation of the three clients that have these unnecessary steps in the installation process. |
|
Discussion
|
|
All seven of these clients performed excellently on all the test torrents and any one of them will meet your needs as a bittorrent client. There was some slight download speed differentials, but nothing too significant.
Pros: Stable and efficient with a good variety of options. Developers are active and responsive to user requests. Attractive interface. Good help resources. Clean install. Cons: Help resource, though very good, could use some updates. No support for web seeds.
Pros: Low and stable RAM and CPU with all the necessary features. Fastest performance on torrents. Development still seems to be very active and responsive to users. Clean install, no addons etc. Cross platform client. Cons: Support has improved, but could be better. Not that well known and not accepted at many private torrent sites (though the situation is improving). These next three clients include toolbar offers, home page and search engine changes and additional software offers during installation. I suggest that you decline all such offers. Since I have seen so many users complain of the toolbars and changes taking effect after installation, I have put up guides (see Quick Selection Guide) to avoid these unnecessary extras,
Pros: There is a wide variety of options and information within the program and an impressive array of plugins to satisfy any need. Support for VPN and Proxy use is superior. Streaming capability. Cross platform. Cons: Toolbar install and home page change enabled at default on install. Advertisements within free version of Vuze interface (can be avoided by using Classic interface). Highest RAM use of the clients here.
Pros: Excellent speeds on torrents, efficient and stable client with a large amount of features packed into a tiny package. Excellent help resources. Streaming capability. Cons: Has had critical security alerts at Secunia. (though none on this version). Toolbar install (not necessary for program) and search/home page change enabled at default on install. Unnecessary software offered during install. Recent versions of µTorrent have been in disfavor at many private sites, supposedly for reporting to the tracker issues.
Even though the two clients are the same, BitTorrent is still banned at most private torrent sites (even though they accept µTorrent). Like µTorrent, BitTorrent is a small and efficient bittorrent client with a great deal of features and will appeal to many despite the "extras" in the installation. These last two clients offer a clean installation and performed excellently on the test torrents. Their lack of support and some features is the reason they are last on this review.
Pros: Efficient and stable with excellent speeds. Simple interface. Clean install, no addons etc. Cons: Not an "official" release of the Transmission team and is lacking help resources. Missing some features
Pros: Small, efficient and fast bittorrent client. Lowest RAM use of the suggested clients. Cons: Missing some features. Support is weak. Releases have been sporadic. |
|
Related Products and Links
|
|
A full listing of the bittorrent help pages here at Gizmo's Freeware is now at There are also links to the guides for each suggested bittorrent client in the Quick Selection Guide below. |
- Article type:
- Login or register to post comments
Printer-friendly version


Comments
Thanks for the info on Tixati. I can not believe I missed that. It is a part of my speed guide to select IPv4 preferred.
I would suggest "IPv4 only" to be safe on any VPN. I did hear back from Direct on the IPv6 and they were honest that it was an issue. They are looking to cure it in the next release.
This is the one site that consistently showed my true IPv6 (the VPN IPv4 tho) on all of the VPNs I tested, even with IPv6 disabled on my computer connection.
http://www.test-ipv6.com/
I am not sure where I got the info on no records. I looked at the site, but did not see it. It might have been an email as I did ask the sites. You could always ask through their support page.
They will have your IP, but it is unlikely they track where and what you do. Then it is a question of do they keep records of when you signed on, for how long etc.
When writing the providers, I basically asked the two questions here:
http://torrentfreak.com/which-vpn-providers-really-take-anonymity-seriou...
I could be wrong on Direct and records, so you might want to ask them.
Thanks again for the Tixati info.
Steve
A new review is up as of February 8, 2013.
It was a very close call, but Tixati slightly beat out qBittorrent for Top Pick.
All of the clients listed here performed excellently on the test torrents and magnets. The top 5 have all the features the average user would want. The last two are missing a couple.
If you find any errors, please post to let me know. The update process gets my eyes a bit blurry.
I did upload my notes on the testing and the link to these is in the review.
I also updated all of the guides to optimize the speed for these clients. So all the guides are compatible with the latest versions.
Look forward to your comments, whether you agree with me or not. The input of users did have an affect on the top pick.
Steve
For those of us that don't need the extra eye candy qBittorrent is still tops.Speed and efficiency are my usual priorities. Still, great work on the review mr6n8.
Thanks.
Personally, I agree and qBittorrent is still my client.
Still, Tixati, even with its colors and graphs, still runs almost as efficiently as qBittorrent.
As I said, it was a very close decision. I went back and forth a few times on it.
Thanks again
Steve
Good update Steve :). Great to see Tixati as top pick, it fully deserves it... great simple interface, efficient, simple to use with great features, and a clean install devoid of extras, with a great team that responds and listens to users. Couldn't have been a better pick.
I thought you might like that pick :)
Tixati has been close to top pick before. This time, it was a virtual tie with qBittorrent, but your and others opinions pushed it to the top.
Steve
Good to know I had a part in it :D.
Excellent review Steve. Your testing notes show how much work was involved. For me also Tixati and qBittorrent are ahead of the rest. It's just a shame more private trackers don't allow them. All I need now is the Holy Grail of a good, free, torrent friendly VPN with decent usage allowance (unfortunately none of Gizmo's suggestions fit the bill) - I live in hope!
Thanks for that.
As to the VPN, I was going to put together a review of the best free VPNs for torrents, but ran into the issue of IPv6 leaks and gave it up.
If you use Vuze, you can disable IPv6 and set Vuze to only be active when there is a VPN connection.
One of the VPNs I tried impressed me - DirectVPN. No issue running torrents. I usually cap out at about 2MBps without VPN and got 1MBps quite often running DirectVPN. There was conflicting info on bandwidth use, one page said unlimited and another talked about 30GB per month. Either one is very generous.
They claim that they do not keep records, other than your bandwidth usage. There is also a paid version, so I think they will stick around. Installation and use was easy.
The only negative was that you only have access to the USA server. But that did not matter to me. Look for the Lite version here if you want to check it out:
http://www.vpndirect.com/index.php
Steve
Thanks a lot for the info. DirectVPN looks very promising. I'm always concerned about what data VPNs log and what they do with it. Sounds pretty good but, as always, and as you say, we only have their word on this.
As for compatible clients, I'm reluctant to use Vuze due to its various installs/hijacks. Can qBittorrent or Tixati be configured in a similar way to guard against leaks/disconnects, or is Vuze the best in these respects?
qBittorrent does have an option to bind to an interface, though I could not figure out which was the VPN. The option is in Options>Advanced and is called "Network Interface". The drop down menu should show all connections.
I do not know of a way to disable IPv6 in qBittorrent.
I am unaware of any such features in Tixati.
One of the reasons I stopped the article is that I really do not understand much of the IPv6 leak issue. I am not certain if it even matters in bittorrent.
From all I saw Vuze appeared to be the best. The installs etc are a pain, no question about it. I also try to avoid programs with such things. If you want to try it I would suggest using the "Classic" interface (avoid the ads). My new install guide has the info.
Thanks again. I'll go ahead with Vuze and try and avoid the installation pitfalls.
My install guide
http://www.techsupportalert.com/installing-vuze-without-toolbar
A couple links on the VPN and Vuze
http://wiki.vuze.com/w/Proxies_And_VPNs#VPN_Configuration
http://wiki.hidemyass.com/Tutorials:Force_Vuze_to_only_load_Torrents_thr...
The IPv6 settings are at the bottom of the Advanced Network Settings options page. All should be disabled.
Good luck
Again, I really appreciate your excellent advice, but I don't like Vuze for so many reasons. Comodo firewall was going crazy with alerts I lost count of them, and amongst other things I had to compromise security by reinstalling Java. It just isn't worth all the problems. I'll try my luck with Tixati or qbit. If any light can be shed on how they can be configured to guard against VPN disconnects and ipv6 leaks I'd be really grateful.
Ouch.
This article may help with the VPN down issue using outside software.
http://torrentfreak.com/how-to-make-vpns-even-more-secure-120419/
On the IPv6, Direct is an open VPN that is not supposed to have the Ipv6 leak. However, there was one site that could see my IPv6 address with any of the VPNs and even when I disabled IPv6 on my connections. Not sure how, but the rest of the sites (and Check my Torrent IP) did not see my IPv6 address.
So I am not sure the advice there on the IPv6 will work completely.
Thanks a lot. I'll check it out. I've just raised these points on the Tixati and qBit forums so maybe they can shed some more light on things. If I hear anything of interest I'll post here (if this is the right place).
Here or the forum.
Just start a new comment here- we are getting thin.
Thanks
Thanks for the review, but for Deluge it says: "A portable version of this product is available from the developer."
Yet all there is in the downloads is an installer.
Thank you. You are correct and I have changed it.
I do not know if I confused it with another program listed here. Since I have started testing and will be redoing the review, I will make sure to check on all the products instead of assuming they are correct on the portable.
Thanks again
Steve
Deluge works fine for me but I can't get qbittorrent to work at all. Every torrent shows stalled at 0% with nothing downloaded. It will be interesting to see how it does in the next test.
I am currently using qBittorrent 3.0.8. It works perfectly from what I have seen, 3.0.7 had a few bugs which were mainly from libtorrent.
I am running 3.0.8 in my testing and it is running very well.
I have finished 3 rounds of testing (5 torrent or magnet downloads) and there are 10 clients left in the running. At this point, all things considered, it looks like it is coming down to qBittorrent and Tixati for top pick. Though I have a few rounds to go.
I am keeping pretty good notes on the tests and results this time. If anyone wants to see them (nothing exciting). I'll figure a way to post them up.
Steve
Sorry for pestering but when do you think we will see results?
Just finished another round of testing. From here on, I am only going to be testing 3 clients that have a shot at top pick.
I should be finishing testing this week and get the new review up over the weekend. Today is kind of busy, but I will get the notes up either this afternoon or tomorrow.
Steve
I like stats, when could you upload the notes?
I put the notes up here
https://sites.google.com/site/bittorrenttesting2013/home/bittorent-testi...
The clients that will be included in the new review have been selected.
I am going to be doing further testing to determine top pick.
Steve
Thanks for the notes. Great read.
I had the same problem when I tried it on my XP SP3 system.
Seems like every time I open qBittorrent this past couple weeks, there has been an update. I do not know if it is related to the issue you both have.
What version were you guys using?
Not sure if I will get to testing this week. Some things came up. Maybe at the end of the week I can get started.
Steve
I don't remember the version. It was long back when I tried it.