Gizmo's Freeware is Recruiting
We are looking for people with skills or interest in the following:
- Mobile Platform Reviews
- Rootkit Scanner and Remover
- Streaming Media Recorder
- Email Client
- Archive Manager Interested? Click here
Best Free Backup Program
|
Other Language?
|
Read this article in Spanish |
|
In a Hurry?
|
|
|
|
Introduction
|
|
Dear reader: Having tested several dozen different backup utilities I have discovered there are a lot of different opinions among both developers & users about how backup programs should be built and function. It is apparent that when it comes to backup programs there is no such thing as “one-size-fits-all,” because everyone’s backup needs are different. Because of this, the programs reviewed below will attempt to focus on what I believe the needs of the average user are. The main things I am taking into account for the top recommendations are as follows.
Note: There are a lot of free backup programs that have some unique features and excellent functionality that really deserve mentioning, but room here does not allow. If you are looking for more advanced programs, or some specific functionality, please check out the third links in the section directly below. Recommended Reading:
|
|
Discussion
|
|
It supports a variety of backup methods including incremental and differential zip archives which they call “partial backups” and they are presented in clear understandable terminology. Each type of backup can be fine tuned with certain file property parameters, including archive “bit” set and reset. (bit is a type of attribute flag that indicates a file has changed since it was last backed up) Archives can be encrypted if you need extra security. Archives can be automatically named by date stamp and split to any desired size. It supports to backing up to any local, network, or online storage that supports ftp,(SSL included) and it has the built in support for burning files directly to CD/DVD. Backup maker supports restoring files to original or a new location. You can restore a whole backup, or just a single file. A nice search feature is included for finding a desired file in the zip archive. The my only complaints would be that the wizard does not include options for auto selection of commonly backup files and folders, and it does not support backing up open/locked files. Also when I tried to restore a password protected archive, the password entry dialog popped up under the restore window, and for a while I thought the program had crashed or frozen. I had to minimize the main programs windows to enter the password. Another minor inconvenience is a popup nag screen that informs the user that the free version is for personal use only, and that it will be removed if you register it for commercial use. Other than that there is no difference between the free and commercial versions. In testing the program on Win 7, I found all features to work as advertised. It is easy enough for a beginner to use, but robust enough for a pro. It has a decent help file in pdf form that covers each aspect of the backup process if you encounter any problems. I think Backup Maker is a great all around file backup program, and give it my top recommendation.
The major reason I am recommending it here is because of a feature it has inherited from its commercial siblings in the Backup4all family, namely its ability to use application specific backup plugins to backup a variety of settings and databases for popular programs. For example there are plugins that will help you set up automatic backups of popular email clients like Outlook Express, Windows Mail, or Mozilla Thunderbird. There is also a dedicated forum for FBackup and support for bugs, errors, and other problems seems quite decent. Overall it does what it does quite well, and while a little light on features, still offers some very desirable functionality. Genie Timeline Free Edition: This is a very nice looking simple backup The developers of Genie Timeline, call this software a Continuous Data Protection (CDP) solution. However, with the free version, it would be better called a hourly CDP, as the automatic backup feature is locked in at 1 hour intervals. (Although you can manually run the backup at any time you wish.) Still monitoring of file changes is done in real-time and your protection level is displayed by a percentage along with the time until the next automatic backup will occur. Be aware that Genie Timeline is more that just a simple backup program, but as the name, Timeline, suggests it is also a versioning program. That is, it keeps older versions of any files that change, so you can “go back in time” and get different revisions of the same file. Unfortunately in the free version, the feature to consolidate and purge unnecessary old files is disabled. This could lead to maxing out a hard drive fairly quickly if you work will a lot of larger size files, that change frequently, such as video files. In order to avoid this problem, you might consider pairing this program with another backup solution, and selectively using Genie Timeline’s features only on files and folders where frequent backups and versioning are desired.
|
|
Related Products and Links
|
| You should also check out the categories Best Free Folder Synchronization Program, and Best Free Drive Imaging Program which are similar and other types of backup programs. |
See the following website for free plugins for your favorite program. http://www.backup4all.com/en/backup-plugins.html
|
Editor
|
| This software category is maintained by volunteer editor Ritho. Registered members can contact the editor with any comments or questions they might have by clicking here. |
|
Tags
|
| best free back up programs, top backup programs, free backup tools, free backup utility, free disk backup, free drive backup free disk imaging, free file based backup and sync, free folder sync programs. |
Back to the top of the article
- Article type:
- Login or register to post comments
Printer-friendly version






Comments
Areca Backup doesn't support writing to CD/DVD
"In Program" CD/DVD support is not really that important anymore. You can simply put a DVD in your burner, select it as the target Windows will set up a stage folder for it and the files will automatically be written to the DVD. Areca also supports splitting up archive files into any what ever size you want or need, which is perfect for creating a set of 4.7 GB files ready to be written to DVD with your favorite burner.
Does seem very interesting but appears to be only for Windows 2000/XP. I'll keep a watch as I will need a backup program for Windows Vista & 7. Anyway, I'll stay tuned!
Actually the somewhere Vista Support is mentioned. I have been testing how it functions on Windows 7 professional 32bit and so far have had no problems at all. Their forums indicate that it works well with 7 as well.
Comodo BackUp is a GREAT freeware. Should be in the list.
Thanks for taking the time to comment. I agree that Comodo Backup has matured quite a bit, and is on its way to becoming a decent product. I do have a few complaints about it though.
Note: Comodo has release a new version of their backup product, Comodo Backup 3.0, and that may negate some of the criticisms below.
1. No differential or incremental style backups. How can this be? Even the most basic backup software has such features.
2. Only a proprietary compression format for backup. At the very least they could include Zip as an alternative.
3. If you are going to use a proprietary compression format, at least offer a rescue system in case of a major crash. How does quickly get at his back ups without first having to do a full install of Windows, followed by Comodo Backup just to open his archives. That is just silly! A simple bootable disk feature would be such an easy solution.
4. Does it do backup verification? Maybe. Nobody is really sure about it. The verify feature is hard to find, because it only shows up when you go to "Restore." You can verify before you restore? What good is that? It is a little late to verify your backup if you need to restore. So okay you can still use it immediately after you make a backup, but it seems strange to have to go to restore to access it. Then there is the matter of the method. All they say is that it verifies the integrity of the backup file. That sounds to me like it verifies it can be read by CB, but does not say it actually verifies each file in the backup against corruption. I feel like this all important feature, could really let you down hard. No way would I ever use CB's archive format to store my data without a something like a hash check of every file being done. Even with simple copy there should be something.
5. This one is minor, but they claim backup support for open and locked files. They don't however use shadow copy but rather their own method. In my testing it fails to copy locked files at certain times. It is better to not claim it than to claim it and not deliver.
Ritho, I couldn't agree more, I was about to post basically the same thoughts. I have used a number of Comodo products over the years (currently CIS which has matured considerably and seems to do a good job) but their backup product is nowhere in the same league and should NOT be listed here unless they make significant changes.
I disagree slightly one one point, that of ZIP files or equivalent. In this day of cheap gargantuan storage, I can't stress enough how important it is that the backup software at least offer the option of copying/backing files AS THEY ARE, with no compression or changes to checksums whatsoever.
I'm still using my old registered (paid) copy of SecondCopy for basic data files. It has incremental backups (up to 9 versions) which is incredibly useful when a file gets corrupted (Photoshop users will relate...) BUT it drives me crazy because the author still doesn't give a hoot about using VSS, so even a simple 3 Kb Wordperfect file in use generates errors and doesn't get backed up.
I've temporarily solved that problem by using Genie Timeline Free which has no incremental features but does a superb job of running in the background unnoticed while saving just about any opened file to an external USB drive.
But if anyone knows of a free backup program (aside from GFI free which I have extensively tested and is IMHO way too buggy to deserve its TSA ranking) that does incrementals while also using VSS correctly, I'm all ears!
I agree about saving files as they are, as that is the way I personally store files. Besides that a lot of the files I backup are image files which for the most part won't compress anyway. The reason I say they should offer none proprietary compression if possible is so that the files can be accessed without using the program itself.
I also agree that GFI does not deserve its ranking. It sort of inherited it from Titan Backup, which was a Gizmo's original 46 best I believe. (Before this site was born) But it is time to move on. They have ignored the problems to long, in the free version.
I Do like Genie Timeline, and it will probably make it in the list with reservations. I don't believe it allows for more than one job at a time. I just am not sure where the delta / block level style backup comes into play, because it seems to create multiple copies of the same file. Any idea about that?
Ritho
Actually after a little research I answered my own question about the block level backup. It only applies to Outlook pst files apparently. Silly! Why not allow the user the choice of which files to apply delta technology to?
Gave up on FBackup. Tried GFI Backup next...What a horrible product. Backup sceduling does not work properly at all, and I spent a few hours playing with it. Auto-rescheduling doesn't reschedule according to working days. Scheduled periodic backup on shutdown does backups on EVERY shutdown. The scheduler seems to be entirely worthless. If this is how it worked for you, how could you possibly give it a 9 out of 10 rating? Perhaps the scheduler broke in the most recent build which you haven't reviewed. Is there a way to get my hands on earlier builds?
Scheduling in GFI Backup has been buggy from the git go. Titan Backup (GFI's Ancestor) did not suffer from these issues. I keep hoping that GFI developers will fix these issues, but as of yet it seems to have been ignored in the freeware.
Will Fbackup automatically reschedule missed tasks? In other words, if the computer is off during a scheduled time, will Fbackup run the backup the next time the computer boots? If not, which of these backup programs does that?
I wonder why "Comodo Backup" isn't mentioned?
It's FREE, and although I only tried it briefly it seemed like a capable product and I'd like to see how it stands compared to applications mentioned in this review.
http://backup.comodo.com/
~Yaser
What about Saftbackup?
http://www.saftware.net/en/index.html
Also read:
http://www.addictivetips.com/windows-tips/backups-made-quick-and-easy-with-saft-backup-windows/
None of the backup programs are as good as Cobain Backup, it's simple, flexible reliable and runs on Win 7 and best of all it's free.
Well, I would agree, except that it does not take into account the fact that a lot of people use external media (USB stick, external hard drive). And that they often forget to stick it in or switch it on! And than Cobian will just report that the backup failed but I know by experience that a lot of people don't even look at the blinking icon anymore to see whether the backup had errors or not. They wanted a set-and-forget system and that is how they use it!
I asked Cobian to be able to generate a customizable prompt before backup starts, along with a timer in which you can specify how long the tool has to wait before it cancels the backup job because the destination (or source) is not available. But he replied that his tool is designed for unattended usage, so no pop ups. A pity.
Actually, I just got across this forum and saw that there is a real user experience available here. Maybe someone can point me to the tool I am looking for.
Such a prompt and/or wait option can also be useful if you want to do backups from/to network drives at systems start up. Since not all systems are up and running at the same time (it may even vary from day to day), it would be useful to be able to tell the backup job to wait a couple of minutes before it triggers the job. If then, within the specified time period, the remote drive is still not available, then the job should be skipped.
Otherwise Cobian is great, it now also includes mirror copying with a simple "safe mirror" concept: All files and folders that are deleted from the destination because they are no longer present in the source, are still kept in a separate place. But this "safe mirror" is common to all backup tasks so it might be difficult to find the deleted files you are looking for if you have several mirror backups with similar or identical folder structures and names.
I also use Drive Image XML for imaging purposes, great tool. And people who are looking for partition copying, resizing, and so on, should use EASEUS PARTITION MANAGER. The Home edition is freeware and really works great.
Frutchy,
It is regrettable that Cobain does not have the feature you mentioned, as I can see it would be quite useful. I think I have run across backup programs that request that you plug in a volume if it is not found and proceed with the backup as soon as it became available, but alas I can remember the name of it. Hopefully one of the readers here can make a suggestion. In the mean time you might want to ask in our forum. In the section called "I want a freeware program that.."
Ritho
Editor
I think another software that deserves to be tried is Uranium Backup: http://www.uraniumbackup.com
Very stable and lightweight and portable.
Uranium backup looks ok, and its portable, BUT the free version doesn't have VSS (need to buy minimum of Gold version).
Thanks
Mark
For disc image backup what about macrium reflect, brilliant
Useful post. Thank you.
I use and recommend Handy Backup, it's easy and reliable backup software, and works great...
http://www.handy-backup.com - freeware
Best,
MikeGeek
I have removed the link pointing to the trial version of the product. Please, we are a freeware site... so post about freeware only. Anything commercial, or shareware, and it will be removed.
Best free backup software is Dmailer http://www.dmailer.com/dmailer-backup.html why? because:
-It is easy to use
-It has features that many of other backup softwares don't
-Is so simple and easy that you can even learn ur dog to use it when he lost a movie with scooby-doo
-The online storage features save you from many problems
It doesn't support writing to cd/dvd, it's not traditional backup software but more like time machine
Dmailer is OK and simple, however it will not backup Outlook nor Mozila files. It focuses purely on basic data files: Pics, Videos, etc. At least from what I could ascertain. When I emailed them, they indicated you had to buy Sync to get the Favorites backup capability. Has anyone else found differently??
Just installed Toucan and tested - a bit slow on the initial sync but subsequent sync/incremental is very fast. Highly recommended. Thanks for the above review and links.
Backup at shutdown - that's all I need! Is that asking too much? My top requirement is that once I have set up the backup parameters in the program, it takes care of itself: when I've finished with the pc for the day I want to hit Start/Shutdown and know that the backup will kick in, do its job and then shut down the machine while I'm safely tucked up in bed.
GFI was fine until it hit the 255 character limit, so that's no longer suitable, and Fbackup doesn't have a 'backup at shutdown' option. In fact most of the ones I've tried fail on that score.
Can anyone recommend one that does what I want please?
Cobian allows you to shutdown the computer upon completion of the backup task(s). Click it and forget it.
I use and highly recomend CrashPlan, from Code42 Software can be found a crashplan.com, the home version is completly free. Can back up to extrenal hard drive, another computer on same network, or a friend in a completly house.
Thank you for your web site -- most useful.
I downloaded GFI and had problems, and then downloaded Cobian. Here are my impressions. SUMMARY: I've gone with Cobian.
Pros and Cons of GFI and Cobian.
GFI:
- GFI won’t write to discs prepared using Windows Vista. Needs discs prepared with Nero.
+ GFI writes much faster than Cobian (have not checked Cobian on Nero discs).
- GFI won’t complete DVD verification without manual intervention. After writing to DVD, it spits the DVD out and then reloads it and says you must reload manually so it can continue.
- GFI appears to cause Windows crashes when a USB stick is used as the destination of its backups.
- GFI will only do incremental backups if backups are compressed. It does not support zipping files individually, so one error loses the lot.
+ GFI has an easy interface for saving settings, but doesn’t have add-ins for all applications. (Its VSS won’t cope with all files.) Most of these settings appear to be bits of the Registry. GFI’s help includes: “You can include your Windows registry in the backup. Important notice: this feature should be used with caution, as restoring the Registry can be very dangerous for a novice user and can crash the system.”
- GFI’s help and logs are not nearly as helpful as Cobian’s.
Cobian:
- Cobian appears to be very slow writing to disc. Have only tried Windows prepared discs so far, and Windows writes very slowly also. Answer appears to be that Cobian does not include disc writing software and uses another application – I guess it’s using Windows. However, writing to hard disk and then copying (using Nero) to DVD seems to be as quick as using GFI to write direct to DVD.
+ Cobian allows incremental and differential back-ups without compression.
+ Cobian allows zipping of files individually.
+ Cobian’s help and logs are much better than GFI’s, and helped me understand some of GFI's problems.
- Cobian recommends that only one’s own files are backed-up, as the system can be recreated in the case of a failure. It does not have GFI's easy interface for saving settings (but one could identify some settings areas using GFS). GFS cautions one about restoring the registry.
- There is no reference to verification in Cobian. I don’t know if the back-up is verified or not. YES – found it in the forum. Under Options/Engine, tick “check CRC for uncompressed operations”.